Best American General of All Time?

[Smitty-48]

In a war with MacArthur vs Patton, who do you think would win, assuming they had the same quality of men same budget etc? Patton forte seemed to be speed, but MacArthur did some ballsy stuff like Inchon.

It all comes down to logistics. If things are equal, that's a stalemate.

[heydaralon]

In a war with MacArthur vs Patton, who do you think would win, assuming they had the same quality of men same budget etc? Patton forte seemed to be speed, but MacArthur did some ballsy stuff like Inchon.

It all comes down to logistics. If things are equal, that's a stalemate.

Giap vs. Zhukov?

[Smitty-48]

In a war with MacArthur vs Patton, who do you think would win, assuming they had the same quality of men same budget etc? Patton forte seemed to be speed, but MacArthur did some ballsy stuff like Inchon.

It all comes down to logistics. If things are equal, that's a stalemate.

Giap vs. Zhukov?

Logistics.

All war is attrition in the end, and its all about logistics.

[heydaralon]

Zimmerman vs Trayvon Martin?

[Smitty-48]

Zimmerman vs Trayvon Martin?

Who are they?

[heydaralon]

I am reading right now about Winfield Scott. Dude served for 53 years. Holy shit. Fought in both the war of 1812 and the civil war. Boss. As. Fuck.

[Smitty-48]

I am reading right now about Winfield Scott. Dude served for 53 years. Holy shit. Fought in both the war of 1812 and the civil war. Boss. As. Fuck.

Ignominiously defeated by the Canadians at Queenston Heights

[heydaralon]

I am reading right now about Winfield Scott. Dude served for 53 years. Holy shit. Fought in both the war of 1812 and the civil war. Boss. As. Fuck.

Ignominiously defeated by the Canadians at Queenston Heights

Irrelevant. Led a badass amphibious landing at Vera Cruz, the first of its kind in American history. It was like D-Day except instead of French Villages the troops saw donkey shows and panhandlers.

[Smitty-48]

I am reading right now about Winfield Scott. Dude served for 53 years. Holy shit. Fought in both the war of 1812 and the civil war. Boss. As. Fuck.

Ignominiously defeated by the Canadians at Queenston Heights

Irrelevant. Led a badass amphibious landing at Vera Cruz, the first of its kind in American history. It was like D-Day except instead of French Villages the troops saw donkey shows and panhandlers.

Whupped by untrained Canadian farmers.

[heydaralon]

Ignominiously defeated by the Canadians at Queenston Heights

Irrelevant. Led a badass amphibious landing at Vera Cruz, the first of its kind in American history. It was like D-Day except instead of French Villages the troops saw donkey shows and panhandlers.

Whupped by untrained Canadian farmers.

He was new at the job at that point. I'll bet your first day of work was a lot different than your last one.